Find the Best - Allstate, Progressive, Geico, or State Farm?

Spread the love

Allstate, Geico, Progressive, and State Farm will be the four biggest Auto Insurance companies in the USA. All, therefore, are well known in the business, like financial strength evaluations, and have been in operation for a long time. They held over 50 percent of their market share of automobile insurance coverage according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

Find-best-allstate-progressive-geico-state farm-insurance-reviews
  • The way the 4 largest insurance companies piled up in 5 types
  • Head-to-head cost comparisons of four firms
  • Recap: The way the insurance companies compare

POWERED BYCompare Car Insurance coveragesSimply answer a few, easy questions and we will do the restGO

Proinsurancereviews found out who is finest in five classes and compared these insurance companies.

The positions in each class are recapped in the base.

Following is a fast look at the way the insurance companies compare, arranged by their position in Proinsurancereviews 2020 finest auto insurance firms analysis. You might even observe every organization's best traits -- the classes where it ranked first or second from Proinsurancereviews different, comprehensive contrast of the four biggest insurers.

BusinessTop features
1. GeicoPrice, technician, client satisfaction
2. State FarmCost, client satisfaction
3. ComplexCoverage alternatives, few complaints
4. AllstateCoverage alternatives, technology, few complaints

The way the 4 largest insurers stack up in 5 types

We looked at coverage choices, customer complaints, client satisfaction, cost and programs and technician to view the nation.

Best for cost: Geico

Cost is king and little else matters just as much. Geico is well worth checking out if this describes you. Costing $300 less annually, normally, than another lowest big insurance company (State Farm), Geico rankings the lowest priced one of the four firms from Proinsurancereviews 2020 analysis. And with over 15 automobile insurance discounts available, Geico provides additional ways to save compared to Allstate, Progressive, or State Farm.

To rank by cost, we utilized national prices for a coverage policy for a motorist with a clean background and great credit. Here are those typical rates:

  1. Geico: $1,198 Each Year.
  2. State Farm: $1,511 Each Year.
  3. Progressive: $1,766 Each Year.
  4. Allstate: $1,834 Each Year.

Rates may fluctuate based on factors like model, automobile make and sex, age, and place. Geico can provide a much better rate Though Allstate may have the auto insurance quote to get a man residing in Georgia. The only way to tell what firm will suit your needs best would be to search around for auto insurance estimates on your own state.

Click on your country to find the cheapest auto insurance there
ConnecticutDelawareDistrict of Columbia
NebraskaNevadaNew Hampshire
New JerseyNew MexicoNew York
North CarolinaNorth DakotaOhio
Rhode IslandSouth CarolinaSouth Dakota
West VirginiaWisconsinWyoming

Fewest customer complaints: Sophisticated

Owing to the size, Progressive had the complaints in accordance with three decades' worth of information in the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.

Nevertheless, it wasn't the insurer that is big with behaviour: Geico and Allstate had complaints that are fewer than expected. State Farm had insurance.

Finest for client satisfaction: State Farm

State Farm's clients report greater overall satisfaction compared to others, based on J.D. Power and Consumer Reports data. Satisfaction surveys comprise claims, pricing, and customer support questions.

Geico was a place; as State Farm, it rated the same in Consumer Reports polls.

Finest for policy alternatives: Allstate

Out of 11 coverage demands we looked for -- for example injury forgiveness and gap insurance -- Allstate provided 10. Progressive followed offering eight.

Here are some differences:

  • Allstate provides equally gap insurance and new-car replacement, while Progressive simply offers gap insurance. Insurers offer just one or another, in any respect, Since the policy is comparable. State Farm and Geico provide.
  • Neither Allstate nor Progressive provides mechanical breakdown insurance. Of the four, just Geico does.

Greatest for technology and programs: Geico

Consumers anticipate programs for providers and internet experiences, and insurance is no exception. Geico stands out for being:

  • An in-app vehicle-care attribute to keep an eye on your vehicle's upkeep.
  • Locators from the program for gasoline, parking, and nearby attractions.
  • A voice-activated source for Amazon's Alexa and Google Assistant and an in-app Digital helper.

The three insurers have some technology characteristics that are comparable, but Geico gets the most.

Extra attributes

If you're searching for a specific attribute from your insurance provider, you might discover it using some rather than others. These are a few of the choices which place the four biggest auto insurers apart. Some cost additional; others are added at no additional cost when you purchase a policy. Star evaluations have come from the 2020 standing of the auto insurance businesses of Proinsurancereviews.

BusinessCoverage choicesTech and programs

Proinsurancereviews score

Incident forgiveness.
Gap insurance.
New-car replacement.
Usage-based insurance.
Deductible rewards.
Reward for injury avoidance.
Audio system policy.

Escape Path uses augmented reality to make a path to security in the event of a fire.
Drivewise safe driving rewards program.
Parking locator.
Gas cost locator.
Alexa voice Support.

Proinsurancereviews score

Incident forgiveness.
Mechanical breakdown policy.

Neighborhood attractions locator.
Parking locator.
Gas locator.
Lyft integration in program.
Automobile maintenance alarms.
In-app Digital helper.
In-app chat.
Google Assistant and Alexa voice Support.

Proinsurancereviews score

Gap insurance.
Incident forgiveness.
Usage-based insurance.
Deductible rewards.
Custom components policy.

Google Home voice Support.
State Farm

Proinsurancereviews score

Usage-based insurance.

Drive Safe & Save program to make discounts for good driving.
Stay Clear training program for youthful drivers.

Alternatives Available from all four insurance companies

These insurers have been some time so that they understand which attributes are no-brainers to offer you. Concerning technology and coverage choices, Progressive, Geico, Allstate, and State Farm have these characteristics in common.

Frequent policy alternativesRideshare insurance.
Roadside assistance and towing.
Rental settlement, even if your car is at the shop for a claim that is insured.
Frequent tech abilitiesIn-app charge cover.
View and download ID card from program.
Submit asserts in program or on the Internet.
Track asserts in program or on the Internet.
See coverage data in program.
Publish damage photographs in program.

When you narrow your options down to two businesses, a look at the gaps can allow you to understand which insurance company is most effective for you. Have a peek at these comparisons of all the four auto insurance companies.

Geico vs. Progressive

If you think about Geico vs. Progressive, consider if you would rather low rates or need extra choices. Geico has reduced average prices within our investigations, while Progressive provides protection that Geico does not have, including gap policy and usage-based insurance, even in which a program monitors your driving behaviors in exchange for reductions or other benefits.

Geico has scores for client satisfaction and program offerings compared to Progressive and robust technology. Both businesses both get fewer than the variety of complaints regarding insurance companies.

Typical Yearly Auto Insurance prices
Great motorist, Fantastic charge$1,198$1,766
Good motorist, Bad credit$1,748$3,238
Driver using current at-fault mishap$1,888$2,980
Minimum policy$478$774

Allstate vs. State Farm

If you are picking between Allstate and State Farm, you have chosen two firms that get fewer complaints to state authorities, relative to their size, compared to Geico or Progressive.

To pick between Allstate and State Farm, think about what is most important to youpersonally. State Farm has average costs in our investigations, though you ought to get estimates to make sure it is more affordable for you. Allstate offers features which are not available from State Farm, for example new-car replacement insurance and injury forgiveness.

AllstateState Farm
Typical Yearly Auto Insurance prices
Great motorist, Superior charge$1,834$1,511
Good motorist, Bad credit$2,907$3,114
Driver using current at-fault mishap$2,904$1,968
Minimum policy$784$624

Geico vs. State Farm

State Farm and geico are cheaper on average than Progressive or Allstate, based on our investigation. However, State Farm in most four cost comparisons rated not more economical than Geico below. Client satisfaction is ranked high for by both.

Geico gets the advantage for options like aid and a program function to keep an eye on the maintenance of your car. State Farm might be your option if you would like reductions in exchange, or insurance for allowing your behaviours are monitored by the company, which Geico does not offer.

GeicoState Farm
Typical Yearly Auto Insurance prices
Great motorist, Fantastic charge$1,198$1,511
Good motorist, Bad credit$1,748$3,114
Driver using current at-fault mishap$1,888$1,968
Minimum policy$478$624

Allstate vs. Geico

When you are picking between Allstate and Geico, you can expect lots of technology choices: One of the four biggest insurance companies, Geico has the many features in its own programs, also Allstate is a powerful second. Both provide programs and technology than State or Progressive Farm.

Geico might be perfect for you if the cost is your primary concern. The evaluation of insurance prices of Proinsurancereviews found Geico is less expensive than Allstate. However, if you're searching for coverage alternatives that are certain, Allstate might have everything you want. Allstate presents a number of choices that Geico does not, such as new-car replacement policy and usage-based insurance.

Typical Yearly Auto Insurance prices
Great driver, Fantastic charge$1,834$1,198
Good motorist, Bad credit$2,907$1,748
Driver using current at-fault mishap$2,904$1,888
Minimum policy$784$478

Progressive vs. Allstate

One of the four carriers, for their policy choices stand out. You can get coverage for stereos or custom components, and you'll be able to lower your accident-free that is deductible by remaining. Those choices are not accessible from State or Geico Farm.

Progressive has complaints, although allstate scores Progressive for client satisfaction. Progressive beats against Allstate on cost, but not necessarily. It is well worth getting estimates to understand which will be more economical since they close on cost.

Typical Yearly Auto Insurance prices
Great motorist, Fantastic charge$1,834$1,766
Good motorist, Bad credit$2,907$3,238
Driver using current at-fault mishap$2,904$2,980
Minimum policy$784$774

Progressive vs. State Farm

Consider if you would like to have more coverage alternatives, or if cost matters more when you are picking between Progressive and State Farm.

State Farm contains client satisfaction scores and is more economical, on average. Complex, on the other hand, offers many policy options which are not accessible from State Farm, such as gap insurance coverage, accident bias and policy for custom components and gear.

ProgressiveState Farm
Typical Yearly Auto Insurance prices
Great motorist, Fantastic charge$1,766$1,511
Good motorist, Bad credit$3,328$3,114
Driver using current at-fault mishap$2,980$1,968
Minimum policy$774$624

Cost1. Geico
2. State Farm
3. Progressive
4. Allstate
Complaints1. Progressive
2. Allstate
3. Geico
4. State Farm
Satisfaction1. State Farm
2. Geico
3. Allstate (tie)
3. ) Progressive (tie)
Coverage alternatives1. ) Allstate
2. Progressive
3. Geico
4. State Farm
Programs and technician1. Geico
2. Allstate
3. State Farm
4. Progressive


Proinsurancereviews averaged rates for 40-year-old people for many ZIP codes in any of the 50 states and Washington, D.C., where the insurance company had been among the biggest insurance firms (by premiums written). "Great drivers" had no moving violations on an insurance credit rating considered"great" by every insurer; a"great driving" reduction was contained for this particular profile. Drivers needed policy limitations:

  • $100,000 bodily injury liability coverage for each individual.
  • $300,000 bodily injury liability policy per crash.
  • $50,000 property damage liability policy per wreck.
  • $100,000 uninsured motorist bodily injury protection per individual.
  • $300,000 uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage per accident.
  • Collision policy with $1,000 deductible.
  • Comprehensive policy with $1,000 deductible.

In nations minimal coverages were inserted.

We used the Very Same assumptions for many motorist profiles

  • For motorists with minimal policy, we corrected the amounts above to reflect no more than the minimum policy required by legislation in the nation.
  • We altered the charge score from"great" to"bad" as reported on the insurer to find prices for drivers with bad credit.
  • For motorists with a single at-fault accident, we included one at-fault accident costing $10,000 in property damage.

A 2016 Toyota Camry LE was utilized by us and presumed miles. In all scenarios, electronic funds transfer reduction and a reduction proved applied. These are sample levels. Your rates will differ.


Proinsurancereviews car insurance ratings reward firms for customer-first characteristics and practices. Tests are based on weighted averages such as site transparency, customer complaints, financial strength, and worth. With our editorial discretion, we consider customer satisfaction polls. These evaluations are a guide, however, we invite you to shop around and compare insurance quotes to get the very best rate for you. Proinsurancereviews doesn't get payment.


Proinsurancereviews analyzed complaints received by state insurance companies and reported on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners in 2016-2018. To evaluate insurance companies compare to another, the NAIC computes a criticism index measuring share of premiums from the business, or its share of complaints relative to its dimensions. To appraise the complaint history of a company,Proinsurancereviews calculated that a similar indicator for every insurance company, measured by market shares of each subsidiary. Ratios are decided for home, automobile and life insurance

Go to Geico website

Go to Progressive website

Go to All State website

Go to State Farm website

Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

Leave a Comment