If Carry-On Luggage Is Not Carry-On Size

Spread the love

If you rely on Producers' size Asserts?

Consumer Reports' evaluations that are luggage-measuring show the solution.From Susan Feinstein

For most airline travelers, the carry-on bag is a superb way to save money and time --they could bypass baggage claim and prevent the hefty fees for checked baggage.

But if you are out there for a new carry-on bag --on your own or as a holiday present --Consumer Reports has a significant heads-up: Carefully assess some carry-on tote prior to buying.

The reason? You can not always require the item measurements found on the totes' hangtags or onto a vendor's site. It must be 22 inches high x 14 inches wide x 9 inches for travel on among the airlines--Delta, American, and United --for example. Other airlines have distinct carry-on principles.

If you want to see - Learn to Trade the Market 5 Steps

Carry-On Complaints

We had been also tipped off about this carry-on bag size issue by client opinions on Amazon.com and eBags.com suggesting the carry-on bags that they purchased were bigger than promoted. By Way of Example, this comment was left by 1 client about a purse he purchased via Amazon:

"BEWARE! This tote has been exhibited as a carry-on, and that's the reason it was bought by me. But it won't fit in the airline"sizers" which are emerging at checkin and gate counters. There's an excellent possibility that if brokers are assessing bag dimensions, you'll be told you must confirm the tote (defeating the purpose of purchasing a carry on luggage!) ."

And that one on Amazon from a different traveler:

"I purchased this as a carry on it's promoted as a continuation. It's too large to fit in the overhead bin. It is not the 22 inches manage towards the front of the bin and also so will fit not the way. With airlines charging check tote fees I do not understand how anybody can make a tote an inch and a half too long and call it a continue."

And by an eBags.com client:

"I'm EXTREMELY disappointed! This carry-on' is larger than promoted. There's not any way it could be permitted as a carry-on on a global flight."
We measured the height, width, and thickness of every piece of luggage by using a measuring box using a laser level.

If Carry-On Luggage Is Not Carry-On Size-If you rely on Producers' size Asserts?-

Consumer Reports Gets Onboard

So we decided to see for ourselves. We purchased 11 parts of bag. Our measurements were performed with a measuring box comprising a laser level.

Before we began measuring we needed to deal that some totes -- specifically bits that are soft-sided -- have in some specific locations. Measurements may not reflect true size of this bag.

To guarantee accurate, uniform dimensions, we flattened the opposing surfaces of every carry-on by putting a 21-inch-long x 10.5-inch-wide bit of plywood onto top surface, using a 10-pound weight set on top of the timber. We measured each measurement -- thickness, width, and height . (See the photograph below.)

If Carry-On Luggage Is Not Carry-On Size-If you rely on Producers' size Asserts?-

How Can the Bags Measure Up?

We discovered that eight were bigger than promised from the manufacturer. (View the table, below.)

As an instance, the TravelPro Maxlite 3 21" Expandable Spinner ($280) is tagged as being 21 inches high x 14 inches wide x 9 inches deep. A bag of these measurements would be in the size limitation for national carry-on American, Delta, and United-- 22 inches high x 14 inches wide x 9 inches deep.

But when we measured the tote, the true dimensions was 22.5 inches x 14.75 inches x 9 inches--surpassing the organization's maintained size by 1.5 inches in length and 0.75 inches in diameter.

Even carry-ons from firms that topped the record for durability and ease of taking within our poll of luggage manufacturers revealed inconsistencies between the promoted and our measured measurements.

Bags Brand/Model (cost *)Manufacturer-Designated Size
(H x W x D, inches)
Consumer Reports Measurement
(H x W x D, inches)
American Tourister
iLite Xtreme 21" Spinner ($99.99)
21 x 14.5 x 823.5 x 15.25 x 9
Briggs & Riley Domestic Carry-on
Expandable Upright ($499)
22 x 14 x 922.5 x 14.5 x 9.25
Eagle Creek Tarmac 22 ($290)22 x 14 x 922.25 x 15 x 8.5
Kirkland Signature Upright
21.5" Black Carry-on ($99.99)
21.5 x 14 x 8.75 **23 x 14 x 9
Lipault Paris Foldable
2-Wheeled 22" Carry-On ($199)
22 x 14 x 821 x 14 x 8
Samsonite Silhouette Sphere two
21" Spinner ($229.99)
21 x 15 x 822.5 x 16 x 10
SwissGear 7377 20" Carry-on Spinner ($80)20 x 14 x 7.521.75 x 14 x 8.5
Traveler's Choice Sienna 21-Inch
Hybrid Rolling Carry-on Garment Bag ($229.99)
21 x 14 x 922.5 x 14.5 x 8.5
TravelPro Maxlite 3
21" Expandable Spinner ($280)
21 x 14 x 922.5 x 14.75 x 9
Tumi Alpha 2 Regular Traveler
2 Wheeled Carry-on ($645)
24 x 14.5 x 9.524 x 14.5 x 9.5
Victorinox Avolve 22 ($249.99)22 x 13.75 x 1022.5 x 14.75 x 10.5

*Prices reflect manufacturer or merchant cost at early November 2015.
**Dimensions are per label and business site; overall overall dimensions also recorded on back of label.
It seems that lots of manufacturers highlight inner measurements of luggage but not outside projections, like wheels.

If Carry-On Luggage Is Not Carry-On Size-If you rely on Producers' size Asserts?-

Why the Discrepancies in Labeled and Measured Sizes?

It seems that producers concentrate on the bag's measurements to catch space.

A spokesperson for Samsonite reported that the company doesn't quantify wheels or the handles. "We quantify' cable to cable' and'edge to edge' so you have the packaging dimensions," the spokeswoman, Amy DiLisio, stated.

Briggs & Riley told me that its luggage is measured by the business in the base of the case to the handle's peak. But the firm sent us cases of luggage on its site for which the dimensions manage and include the wheels. For the national expandable vertical that we quantified, Riley & Briggs recorded the measurements on the tag and the business side of the bag as the exact same. The label manages from the dimensions and did not mention such as the wheels, but the Briggs & Riley website failed.

However, as soon as we quantified this tote, we discovered it to be within the promised size of 22 inches high x 14 inches wide x 9 inches deep--measuring in 22.5 inches high x 14.5 inches wide x 9.25 inches deep. This dimension is larger than American, Delta, and United dimensions restricted x and you also may need to pay to look at a bag within the size limitation that is carry-on.

Airlines maintenance about your bag's footprint. The outside measurements include the handle in the retracted position, the wheels, and some other projections. All of it takes up space in the bin so that it counts.

All this is vital in site description drive decisions or because the measurements on the item's hangtag. If a manufacturer supplies just the inside measurements, it is not useful if you're searching for a carry-on which complies with your airline's carry-on principles .

Bottom Line

Take a measuring tape over, If you shop for a bag in shops. And if you're ordering online, assess consumer reviews on merchant and manufacturer websites to discover if other owners have confronted problems taking the"carry-on" on the airplane. Also, assess the merchant's return policy. In case.

Editor's Note: once we assessed the policies of these bags contained here, just Costco said it would return its Kirkland luggage after utilized.

Click to rate this post!
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

Leave a Comment